Is Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm Reformulation Better or Worse?

Reformulation Alert
The internet-favorite lip balm just got a new formula — and long-time fans are divided.
Expert Analysis · Honest Reviews · Real Results
**FROM:** Your Beauty Editor Friend
**SUBJECT:** They changed it. I have feelings.

1.💋They Tweaked It

Everyone’s favorite slick lip balm just got a glow-up — or a glow-down, depending on who you ask. Summer Fridays quietly reformulated their Lip Butter Balm and the internet is in shambles.

The old one felt like a thick, glossy hug. The new one? It’s lighter, less sticky, and dries down in about 45 seconds flat. That’s either a miracle or a tragedy — depends on your lip philosophy.

2.🔬What Changed, Actually

It’s still $24 — same price, new vibe. The claim: “more hydration, less slip.” I called BS and bought two shades to test.

1

Texture Shift

Gone is the pudding-thick feel. It’s now more of a balmy oil — thin, silky, almost watery on first swipe.

2

Stickiness Level

Drops from a 7/10 to a 2/10. Hair won’t stick to your mouth. That’s a win for windy days.

3

Scent & Shine

Same vanilla birthday cake scent. Shine is less glass-like, more “healthy gloss.” Less mirror, more everyday.

a bottle of mf hair oil on a beige background

Photo: Mockup Free / Unsplash

3.📦Inside the Tube

They swapped out heavier waxes for lighter emollients. It’s not a lip mask anymore — it’s a daily driver. Here’s what’s doing the work:

  • Shea Butter: softens without sitting on top
  • Jojoba Oil: sinks in fast, mimics skin’s natural sebum
  • Peptides: plump the lip line slightly over time
  • Vitamin E: antioxidant shield against chapping
three makeup brushes on top of compact powders

Photo: Rosa Rafael / Unsplash

4.👍The Wear Test

First swipe: whoa, that’s thin. Almost disappointing. Then it sinks in — like putting on a moisturizer instead of a slug mask. Lips feel *flexible*, not coated.

Two weeks in: I actually prefer it. The old one sat on my lips like a layer of Saran wrap. This one disappears into the skin. Weirdest part — my lips look less chapped in the morning. Didn’t expect that.

💡

One Thing: Apply to damp lips after a sip of water — the hydration locks in twice as long. Dry application = faster fade.
woman getting lips applied with lipstick

Photo: freestocks / Unsplash

5.👎The Real Verdict

My lips feel smoother by noon. No peeling. But the shine? Gone in an hour. If you want that wet-look gloss that lasts through coffee, this ain’t it.

Buy if
You hate sticky lips and want a balm that actually absorbs, not just sits there
⏭️

Skip if
You loved the original’s thick, glossy armor — this is a different beast
💰

Worth it?
$24 for a daily balm that lasts 3 months? Yes. For a lip gloss? No.
6.Final Call

The reformulation is better for *actual lip health*, worse for that Instagram glass-lip moment. I’d call it an upgrade — just don’t expect the same product.

7.8/10
Better for skin, worse for shine
🛍️

Where to Buy: Sephora or direct — grab the mini duo first if you’re on the fence