DHC Deep Cleansing Oil Reformulation: Better or Worse?

Reformulation Alert
The cult-favorite Japanese cleansing oil quietly swapped olive oil for a new base—did they ruin it or perfect it?
Expert Analysis · Honest Reviews · Real Results
🔍 **Olive Oil Who?**

DHC quietly swapped out olive oil for a new base. Nobody told us. The cult-favorite Japanese cleansing oil now runs on a blend of *MCT and mineral oils* — and the internet is losing it.

The real question: does it still melt through sunscreen like butter on a hot pan? Or did they just create an expensive makeup remover with zero soul?

[IMG_1: A side-by-side bottle shot — old label vs. new label, with ingredients list blurred in background]

📋 **What It Is Now**

New formula. Same $28 price tag. Claims to “remove stubborn makeup” without stripping — but that was never the old formula’s problem. The old one *was* the strip club. This one’s trying to be a spa.

1

Waterless base

No water means no dilution — it stays oily until you emulsify

2

Vitamin E + rosemary leaf

Antioxidants that aren’t just shelf decoration

3

No fragrance, no parabens

Smells like… nothing. Which is actually fine.

[IMG_2: A pump of the oil on a dry hand, catching light]

🧪 **Ingredients That Actually Matter**

Old formula: olive oil heavy, thick, almost greasy. New one: MCT oil (caprylic/capric triglyceride) + mineral oil + squalane. Lighter. Faster rinse. But here’s the thing — MCT oil is comedogenic for some people. Mineral oil isn’t. So it’s a trade-off.

  • MCT Oil: Absorbs fast, but can clog pores for acne-prone skin
  • Mineral Oil: Safe, stable, cheap — old-school but effective
  • Squalane: Lightweight hydration, mimics your skin’s natural oils
  • Rosemary Leaf Extract: Antioxidant, not a preservative gimmick

[IMG_3: A close-up of the ingredient list on the back of the bottle]

👍 **The Feel Test**

First pump — watery. Thin. Not the thick, satisfying glide of the original. I actually checked if I got a counterfeit. But it spreads across dry skin like a dream — takes 10 seconds to dissolve a full face of waterproof mascara. Rinses clean in 3 seconds flat. No film. No panic.

Week 2: My skin isn’t angry. That’s the surprise. Old formula left a slight tightness. This one? Nothing. It’s boring in the best way.

💡

One Thing: Pump 3 times — not 2. The thinner texture needs more product to glide without tugging. Trust me.

[IMG_4: Oil emulsifying with water on a white sink surface]

👎 **The Verdict You Actually Want**

My skin stayed clear. Makeup came off completely. No breakouts. No redness. But — and here’s the but — if you loved the original’s heavy, oily feel, this will disappoint. It’s lighter. Less luxurious. More utilitarian.

Buy if
You have oily or combo skin and want a fast, no-residue oil cleanser
⏭️

Skip if
You’re acne-prone and MCT oil breaks you out — patch test first
💰

Worth it?
For $28, yes — if you’re not married to the old texture. But Kose Softymo does the same job for $12.

[IMG_5: A cotton pad after a double cleanse — clean, no residue]

💡 **Final Call**

The new DHC Deep Cleansing Oil is technically better — faster rinse, no tightness, still melts everything. But it lost its soul. It’s now a reliable friend, not a cult icon. I’d buy it again, but I won’t hoard three bottles like I used to.

7.5/10
Better performance, less personality
🛍️

Where to Buy: Amazon or DHC’s site directly — grab the travel size ($8) first if you’re skeptical. Don’t blind-buy a full bottle.