๐
I put Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil on one side of my mouth and a $9 drugstore dupe on the other. Walked around Brooklyn for 4 hours. Ate a bagel. Drank iced coffee.
The cheap one was gone before the first sip. Rare Beauty? Still blushing on my lips like I just got out of a steamy subway car โ in a good way.
๐ฌ
It’s $20. A tinted lip oil with a doe-foot applicator that looks suspiciously like every other gloss tube. The claim: “Hydrating color that lasts.” I rolled my eyes. Then I tested it.
1. **The applicator is weirdly perfect** โ curved like it was molded for my actual lip shape, not a generic wand
2. **The pigment is sheer but builds** โ one swipe = “I woke up like this,” two swipes = “I definitely did my makeup”
3. **The staying power is 3 hours** โ which for an oil is basically a miracle. Oils slide off. This one… doesn’t.
๐ฐ
Castor oil and sunflower seed oil sit at the top. No drying alcohols. No fragrance โ thank god, because that’s what gives me tiny bumps around my mouth. The color comes from iron oxides, not synthetic dyes that stain your teeth pink.
– **Castor Oil:** Locks moisture in without feeling like you licked a candle
– **Sunflower Seed Oil:** Sinks in fast โ 10 seconds, I timed it
– **Iron Oxides:** Actually natural pigment that fades evenly, not patchy
– **Vitamin E:** The reason your lips don’t peel after 3 hours of wear
๐ค
First swipe: feels like olive oil on your lips. Thin. Slippery. I thought, “this is going to be a mess.” Then it settled. Within 30 seconds, it wasn’t sliding around anymore โ just sitting there, looking expensive. The color (I tried “Hope” โ a dusty rose) is exactly what you’d get if you bit your lips and blushed at the same time.
Week 2 update: I wore it to sleep. Woke up with lips that didn’t feel like sandpaper. That’s never happened with a tinted product.
๐ก **One Thing** Apply to completely dry lips. If there’s any balm underneath, it slides off in 20 minutes.
๐
My lips stayed soft for 6 hours after I wiped it off. That’s the part that shocked me. The color faded to a nice stain after lunch. The $9 dupe? Dry by hour 2, color gone by hour 1.
โ
**Buy if** you want a low-maintenance flush that actually hydrates and doesn’t disappear after one sip of water
โญ๏ธ **Skip if** you want full pigment โ this is a “your lips but better” situation, not a lipstick
๐ฐ **Worth it?** For $20, you get better ingredients than most $40 lip products. Yes.
๐
The celebrity brand actually outperformed the drugstore classic. I didn’t want to admit it. But my lips don’t lie.
**8.5/10** โ Actually hydrating, actually lasts
๐๏ธ **Where to Buy** Sephora or rarebeauty.com โ get the mini set first if you’re unsure about the shade